The Worst 401k Plans: Red Flags to Watch For
Not all 401k plans are created equal. Learn to identify the hallmarks of a terrible plan—and what to do if you're stuck in one.
Key Takeaways
- 1Small employers often have the worst plans due to lack of bargaining power
- 2Red flags include: fees over 1%, no index funds, limited choices, no match
- 3Target date funds with high fees are a common trap
- 4Insurance company plans (AXA, VALIC, Prudential) often have highest costs
- 5Revenue sharing and 12b-1 fees indicate conflicts of interest
- 6You can advocate for change or minimize exposure through IRA savings
Red Flags of a Terrible 401k Plan
If your plan has several of these characteristics, you're likely in a subpar 401k:
- Average expense ratio above 1% across all options
- No low-cost index funds (S&P 500, total market)
- Fewer than 10 investment options to choose from
- No employer match or very low match (under 3%)
- Long vesting schedule (6 years to fully vest)
- High administrative fees ($100+/year)
- Target date funds with 1%+ expense ratios
- Mandatory annuity or insurance products
Plan Providers Known for High Costs
While any provider can offer good or bad plans, these have historically had more issues with high fees:
- Insurance companies (AXA Equitable, VALIC, Prudential, Lincoln Financial)
- Small regional banks managing 401k plans
- Third-party administrators with revenue sharing deals
- Any provider pushing proprietary funds exclusively
- Plans with group variable annuity structures
| Provider Type | Typical Issues | Average Extra Cost |
|---|---|---|
| Insurance Company Plans | Surrender charges, high expense ratios | +0.50-1.00% |
| Small Bank Plans | Limited options, high admin fees | +0.30-0.75% |
| Revenue Sharing Plans | Hidden costs, conflict of interest | +0.25-0.50% |
| Well-Run Plans (Vanguard, Fidelity) | Baseline for comparison | 0% |
Common Fee Traps in Bad Plans
Watch out for these specific fee structures that eat into returns:
- 12b-1 fees: Marketing costs passed to you (0.25-1.00%)
- Load fees: Sales charges when you buy or sell
- Wrap fees: Extra layer of management fees on top of fund expenses
- Sub-transfer agent fees: Payments for recordkeeping hidden in fund costs
- Surrender charges: Penalties for moving money, especially in insurance products
- Mortality & expense (M&E) charges: Insurance profit embedded in annuities
Exploring your retirement options?
Our 60-second quiz matches you with the right account type
Why Small Business Plans Are Often Worst
If you work for a small company, your 401k is likely more expensive than large employer plans:
- Less bargaining power: Providers charge more for smaller plans
- Less HR expertise: Benefits managers may not understand fees
- Fewer participants: Fixed costs spread over fewer people
- Targeted by high-fee providers: Small businesses are profitable targets
- Auto-enrollment in expensive defaults: Less oversight of fund selection
| Company Size | Average Total 401k Cost |
|---|---|
| Under 50 employees | 1.50% - 2.50% |
| 50-200 employees | 1.00% - 1.75% |
| 200-1000 employees | 0.75% - 1.25% |
| 1000+ employees | 0.40% - 0.80% |
| Fortune 500 | 0.20% - 0.50% |
What to Do If You're Stuck in a Bad Plan
Even with a terrible 401k, you have options:
- Contribute only enough to get the full employer match
- Choose the single lowest-cost option and put everything there
- Max out IRA contributions where you control the costs
- Advocate with HR for plan improvements
- Document fees for potential DOL complaint if egregious
- Plan to rollover to Gold IRA when you leave the company
The Match Math
Even in the worst 401k plan, an employer match is usually worth it. A 3% match with 2% fees still nets you a positive return. Get the match, then direct additional savings to accounts you control.
Escape a Bad Plan with a Gold IRA
When you leave your employer, you're not stuck anymore. A Gold IRA rollover lets you escape high fees and gain control:
- Transparent, competitive fee structure
- No hidden expense ratios or revenue sharing
- Physical gold that can't be devalued by management fees
- Direct rollover preserves tax-deferred status
- Choose your own custodian and storage options
Frequently Asked Questions
1How do I find out if my plan is bad?
Calculate your total weighted expense ratio. If it's over 1%, you have a high-fee plan. Also check for index fund options—if the cheapest option is over 0.5%, the plan needs improvement.
2Can I refuse to participate in a bad 401k?
Yes, but you'd be giving up any employer match—usually not worth it. Instead, contribute just enough for the match and invest additional savings in accounts you control.
3Is it worth switching jobs over a bad 401k?
Probably not as the sole reason, but it's a factor. Over a 30-year career, a 1% fee difference could cost $300,000+. Factor benefits into your total compensation when evaluating job offers.
Related Articles
Helpful Guides
Interactive Tools
Ready to Protect Your Retirement?
Join thousands of Americans who have secured their savings with physical gold. Augusta Precious Metals makes the process simple.