Self-Directed IRA Real Estate Rules: Complete Compliance Guide (2026)
Understand prohibited transactions, disqualified persons, UBIT/UDFI taxes, and titling requirements for investing in real estate with your SDIRA.
Key Takeaways
- 1All real estate transactions must avoid prohibited transactions with disqualified persons
- 2You cannot live in, vacation at, or personally use IRA-owned property
- 3Property must be titled in IRA name, not your personal name
- 4UBIT/UDFI taxes apply if using debt financing or operating active business
- 5Gold IRA avoids most of these complex rules while providing similar diversification
Self-Directed IRA Real Estate Overview
Investing in real estate through a self-directed IRA can provide diversification and potential returns, but comes with strict IRS rules:
- Requires self-directed IRA custodian allowing real estate investments
- Can invest in rental properties, land, commercial real estate, REITs
- All income and expenses must flow through the IRA
- Gains grow tax-deferred (Traditional) or tax-free (Roth)
- Cannot use sweat equity—must hire third parties for all work
- One mistake can disqualify your entire IRA
Rule Complexity Warning
SDIRA real estate rules are extensive and strictly enforced. The IRS does not accept "I didn't know" as an excuse. One prohibited transaction can disqualify your entire IRA, triggering immediate taxation of the full balance plus potential 10% early withdrawal penalty.
Prohibited Transactions
IRC Section 4975 prohibits certain transactions between your IRA and disqualified persons. Violating these rules disqualifies your entire IRA:
- Cannot buy property from yourself or disqualified persons
- Cannot sell IRA property to yourself or disqualified persons
- Cannot rent IRA property to yourself or disqualified persons
- Cannot live in or personally use IRA-owned property
- Cannot use IRA property for business you own
- Cannot perform repairs or maintenance yourself (sweat equity)
- Cannot lend money between IRA and disqualified person
- Cannot guarantee a loan for IRA property
| Action | Allowed? | Consequence if Violated |
|---|---|---|
| Buy rental from parents | No | Full IRA disqualification |
| Rent to your children | No | Full IRA disqualification |
| Fix a leaky faucet yourself | No | Full IRA disqualification |
| Stay overnight at vacation rental | No | Full IRA disqualification |
| Hire unrelated contractor | Yes | N/A |
| Rent to unrelated tenant | Yes | N/A |
Real IRS Case
In a Tax Court case, an investor's IRA bought a cabin. He stayed there "just a few nights" to check on renovations. The IRS disqualified the entire $300,000 IRA because he personally benefited from an IRA asset. All distributions became taxable immediately.
Disqualified Persons Defined
You cannot transact with these people or entities using your IRA:
- You (the IRA owner)
- Your spouse
- Your lineal ascendants (parents, grandparents)
- Your lineal descendants (children, grandchildren)
- Spouses of lineal descendants
- Any entity you own 50% or more of
- Officers, directors, or highly compensated employees of your company
- IRA custodian, trustee, or fiduciaries
| Relationship | Disqualified? | Can Transact with IRA? |
|---|---|---|
| You | Yes | No |
| Spouse | Yes | No |
| Children | Yes | No |
| Parents | Yes | No |
| Siblings | No | Yes |
| In-laws (spouse's parents) | No | Yes |
| Nieces/Nephews | No | Yes |
| Business partner (unrelated) | No | Yes |
Note: Siblings and in-laws are surprisingly NOT disqualified persons
Safe Harbor Strategy
When in doubt, apply the "stranger test": Would this transaction be appropriate if done with a complete stranger? If the answer involves any personal benefit, family connection, or self-dealing, it's likely prohibited.
Exploring your retirement options?
Our 60-second quiz matches you with the right account type
UBIT and UDFI Taxes
Certain real estate activities trigger Unrelated Business Income Tax (UBIT) or Unrelated Debt-Financed Income (UDFI) even within an IRA:
- UDFI: Applies when IRA uses mortgage/debt to purchase property
- Taxed on income proportional to debt percentage
- Example: 50% financed = 50% of rental income taxable as UDFI
- UBIT: Applies to active business operations (flipping, hotels, etc.)
- Tax rates are trust tax rates (up to 37%)
- IRA must file Form 990-T when UBIT/UDFI exceeds $1,000
- Roth IRA is NOT exempt from UBIT/UDFI
- Can significantly reduce tax advantages of IRA real estate
| Situation | Tax Triggered? | Tax Type |
|---|---|---|
| Cash purchase, passive rental | No | None |
| Mortgaged property, rental income | Yes | UDFI |
| Flipping houses frequently | Yes | UBIT |
| Operating a hotel | Yes | UBIT |
| Triple-net lease, cash purchase | No | None |
| Land held for appreciation | No | None |
UDFI Calculation Example
Your IRA buys a $200,000 rental with $100,000 mortgage (50% debt). Rental income is $18,000/year. UDFI taxable income: $18,000 x 50% = $9,000. At trust tax rates, you could owe $2,000+ in UBIT annually, significantly reducing your tax advantage.
Titling and Administrative Requirements
Proper titling and administration are essential for IRS compliance:
- Property title must be in IRA's name, not yours personally
- Format: "[Custodian Name] FBO [Your Name] IRA"
- All income deposited directly to IRA account
- All expenses paid from IRA account
- Cannot use personal funds for IRA property expenses
- Cannot deposit IRA rental income to personal account
- Must maintain separate accounting for each property
- Annual fair market valuation required for IRA reporting
Correct Title Format
Property title should read: "Equity Trust Company Custodian FBO John Smith IRA" NOT "John Smith." If titled in your name personally, the IRS treats the purchase as a distribution from your IRA, creating immediate taxes and potential penalties.
Compliance Risk Assessment
SDIRA real estate requires meticulous compliance. Common mistakes include: helping with minor repairs (prohibited), letting family stay briefly (prohibited), using personal funds for an emergency repair and reimbursing later (prohibited). Each violation can disqualify your entire IRA. Consider whether the diversification benefits outweigh the compliance burden.
Gold IRA: Simpler Diversification Without the Compliance Burden
Gold IRA provides portfolio diversification with far fewer rules and complications:
- No prohibited transaction concerns with family members
- No UBIT or UDFI taxes—gold generates no income until sold
- Simple titling—custodian handles all administrative requirements
- No property management, tenants, or maintenance headaches
- Highly liquid—sell at market price anytime vs. months to sell real estate
- Augusta Precious Metals handles all compliance and storage requirements
Frequently Asked Questions
1Can I manage my own IRA rental property?
You can oversee the property (choose tenants, set rent amounts, make decisions), but you cannot physically perform any work. All maintenance, repairs, and improvements must be done by hired third parties. You also cannot charge the IRA a management fee for your services.
2What happens if I accidentally violate a prohibited transaction rule?
Intent does not matter to the IRS. Accidental violations carry the same consequence as intentional ones: your entire IRA is disqualified as of January 1st of the violation year. The full balance becomes taxable income, potentially plus a 10% early withdrawal penalty if under age 59 1/2.
3Can my IRA and my spouse's IRA jointly purchase real estate?
Yes, two separate IRAs can partner to purchase real estate, even if owned by spouses. However, neither spouse can personally contribute funds or labor. This is a common strategy to afford larger properties while avoiding disqualified person issues.
4Do I need a special custodian for SDIRA real estate?
Yes, traditional custodians like Fidelity and Vanguard do not allow real estate. You need a self-directed IRA custodian such as Equity Trust, Entrust, uDirect IRA, or Millennium Trust that specializes in alternative assets and understands real estate compliance requirements.
Related Articles
Helpful Guides
Interactive Tools
Ready to Protect Your Retirement?
Join thousands of Americans who have secured their savings with physical gold. Augusta Precious Metals makes the process simple.