Per Stirpes vs By Representation: Distribution Method Comparison
These two terms sound similar but can distribute your inheritance differently. Understanding the difference protects your family from unintended consequences.
Key Takeaways
- 1Per stirpes divides inheritance by family branch at your children's level.
- 2By representation (modern per stirpes) divides at the generation closest to you with living members.
- 3Per capita divides equally among living beneficiaries only - grandchildren excluded.
- 4The difference only matters when beneficiaries die before you.
- 5Most retirement accounts and insurance use per stirpes as default.
Understanding Distribution Terms
These Latin terms describe how inheritance is divided when beneficiaries die before you. The method you choose determines whether grandchildren inherit.
- **Per stirpes:** "By branch" - divides at your children's level
- **By representation:** Modern per stirpes - divides at first living generation
- **Per capita:** "By head" - divides equally among living beneficiaries only
- **Per capita at each generation:** Hybrid approach used in some states
When It Matters
If all your named beneficiaries outlive you, all three methods produce the same result. The difference only appears when someone dies before you.
Per Stirpes (Classic Definition)
**Per stirpes** divides your estate into shares equal to the number of your children (whether living or deceased with descendants), then distributes down each family branch.
- First division: Equal shares for each child (or their descendants)
- If child is alive: They receive their entire share
- If child is deceased with children: Their children split that share
- If child is deceased with no children: Share redistributed to other branches
Per Stirpes Example
$900,000 estate. You have 3 children: - Child A (alive) - receives $300,000 - Child B (deceased, has 2 children) - Grandchildren B1 and B2 each receive $150,000 - Child C (alive) - receives $300,000 Notice: Estate divided by 3 (your children), even though Child B is deceased.
By Representation (Modern Per Stirpes)
**By representation** (also called "per stirpes by representation") divides the estate at the first generation with living members. This is the modern interpretation adopted by most states.
- First division: At the closest generation to you with living members
- More equal treatment of grandchildren
- Prevents "dead hand" control when all children predecease you
- Often produces same result as traditional per stirpes
When They Differ
$900,000 estate. ALL 3 children predeceased you: - Child A had 3 children - Child B had 2 children - Child C had 1 child **Traditional Per Stirpes:** - Child A's 3 kids each get $100,000 (1/3 ÷ 3) - Child B's 2 kids each get $150,000 (1/3 ÷ 2) - Child C's 1 kid gets $300,000 (1/3) **By Representation:** All 6 grandchildren receive $150,000 each (divided equally at grandchild level)
Exploring your retirement options?
Our 60-second quiz matches you with the right account type
Per Capita Distribution
**Per capita** means "by head" - the inheritance is divided equally among all living named beneficiaries. Descendants of deceased beneficiaries receive nothing.
- Only living beneficiaries share the inheritance
- Grandchildren of deceased children get nothing
- Simpler but can disinherit grandchildren
- Often the default when no designation is specified
Per Capita Example - Grandchildren Excluded
$900,000 estate. You named 3 children as beneficiaries per capita: - Child A (alive) - receives $450,000 - Child B (deceased, has 2 children) - grandchildren receive $0 - Child C (alive) - receives $450,000 Child B's children are completely disinherited.
Side-by-Side Comparison
Here is how each method distributes the same $600,000 estate.
- **Per stirpes:** Keeps wealth in family branches
- **By representation:** More equal treatment at each generation
- **Per capita:** Simplest but excludes descendants
| Scenario | Per Stirpes | By Representation | Per Capita |
|---|---|---|---|
| All 3 children alive | Each child: $200k | Each child: $200k | Each child: $200k |
| 1 child dead (w/ 2 kids) | Child A: $200k, Child B: $200k, 2 grandkids: $100k each | Same as per stirpes | Child A: $300k, Child B: $300k, grandkids: $0 |
| All children dead (6 grandkids total) | Unequal shares by branch | Each grandchild: $100k (equal) | Depends on who is named |
Which Distribution Method Should You Choose?
The right choice depends on your family structure and wishes.
- **Choose Per Stirpes (or By Representation) if:**
- You want to protect grandchildren if your child dies first
- You want inheritance to stay in family branches
- You have unequal numbers of grandchildren per child
- You want a "backup plan" that goes down generations
- **Choose Per Capita if:**
- You only want living children to inherit (no grandchildren)
- You want the simplest distribution
- You plan to name grandchildren separately as contingent beneficiaries
- You have a small, simple family structure
- **Default recommendation:**
- Most estate attorneys recommend per stirpes or by representation for retirement accounts, life insurance, and trusts. It provides the most protection against unintended disinheritance.
Review Your Forms
Pull out your beneficiary forms for 401k, IRA, and life insurance. Check what designation you have (if any). If it says nothing or "per capita," consider updating to per stirpes.
Apply These Principles to Your Gold IRA
Your Gold IRA beneficiary designation should include per stirpes language to ensure physical gold passes down your family line as intended. Gold is a multi-generational asset.
- Gold IRA beneficiary forms support per stirpes, by representation, and per capita
- Physical gold can be divided among heirs according to your chosen method
- Unlike digital accounts, physical gold provides tangible inheritance
- Proper beneficiary designation ensures smooth transfer without probate
Frequently Asked Questions
1Are per stirpes and by representation the same thing?
Mostly yes, with a subtle difference. Traditional "per stirpes" always divides at your children's level. "By representation" (modern per stirpes) divides at the first generation with living members. In most scenarios, they produce the same result. The difference only appears when ALL your children predecease you.
2What if I don't specify any distribution method?
If you don't specify, the default varies by institution and state. Many default to per capita (living beneficiaries only), which could disinherit grandchildren. Always explicitly state your preference on beneficiary forms.
3Can I use different methods for different accounts?
Yes. You might use per stirpes for your IRA, per capita for life insurance, and another method for your trust. However, this can create confusion. Most estate planners recommend consistency across all accounts.
4Does per stirpes apply to my spouse as beneficiary?
Per stirpes only matters when beneficiaries are from different family branches (like children or siblings). If your spouse is the sole beneficiary, per stirpes designation is irrelevant. It becomes important if you name multiple people from different family lines.
5Which method do most people use?
Per stirpes (or by representation) is the most common choice for retirement accounts and life insurance, especially when naming children as beneficiaries. It provides the most comprehensive protection and aligns with most people's wishes to keep inheritance in the family.
Related Articles
Helpful Guides
Ready to Protect Your Retirement?
Join thousands of Americans who have secured their savings with physical gold. Augusta Precious Metals makes the process simple.