What Happens to My Retirement If Fidelity or Schwab Fails?
Your entire retirement is with one company. What if they go bankrupt? Here's exactly what protections exist and what would happen to your money.
Key Takeaways
- 1Your securities are legally separate from the brokerage - they are YOUR property
- 2SIPC protects up to $500,000 per customer if a brokerage fails
- 3Brokerage failure does NOT mean you lose your investments
- 4Major brokerages like Fidelity, Schwab, and Vanguard are highly regulated and stable
- 5Physical gold eliminates brokerage counterparty risk entirely
Understanding the Concern
Many people have their entire retirement savings with a single brokerage. Natural questions arise:
- "What if Fidelity goes bankrupt? Is my $500,000 just gone?"
- "Schwab just had issues - should I move my money?"
- "These are private companies - they could fail like any business"
- "What happened to MF Global and Lehman Brothers?"
- "Is my retirement really safe with one company?"
The Good News
The structure of brokerage accounts provides strong protection. Your investments are not "in" the brokerage - they are held in your name, with the brokerage acting as custodian. This is fundamentally different from deposits in a bank.
How Your Retirement Assets Are Held
Understanding the legal structure of your account provides reassurance:
- Securities are held in "street name" but registered to you
- Your investments are legally YOUR property, not the brokerage's
- Brokerages are required to segregate customer assets from their own
- SEC Rule 15c3-3 requires excess customer funds held separately
- Daily reconciliation ensures assets match customer records
- Regular audits by SEC and FINRA verify compliance
| Asset Type | How It's Held | Protection |
|---|---|---|
| Stocks/ETFs | Registered in your name via DTC | Yours - transfers if broker fails |
| Mutual Funds | Separate fund company, broker is agent | Held by fund company |
| Cash Balance | Segregated customer accounts | SIPC up to $250,000 |
| Bonds | Registered to you | Yours - transfers if broker fails |
| 401k Assets | Held in trust, separate from broker | ERISA protected |
SIPC Protection Explained
SIPC (Securities Investor Protection Corporation) provides additional protection if a brokerage fails:
- Covers up to $500,000 per customer (including up to $250,000 in cash)
- Protects against brokerage FAILURE, not market losses
- Steps in when a brokerage cannot return customer property
- Works to transfer accounts to a solvent brokerage
- Has never failed to protect customers within coverage limits
- Most major brokerages also carry excess SIPC insurance
What SIPC Does NOT Cover
SIPC does not protect against: market losses, bad investment advice, fraud by the broker themselves (though it helps recover assets), commodities/futures, or cryptocurrency. It protects against brokerage firm failure, not investment performance.
Exploring your retirement options?
Our 60-second quiz matches you with the right account type
What Actually Happens If a Brokerage Fails
Here is the typical process when a brokerage becomes insolvent:
- Historical examples: Lehman Brothers accounts were transferred within weeks
- MF Global customers eventually recovered most assets
- Drexel Burnham Lambert customers received full SIPC protection
- Modern systems make transfers faster than historical cases
- 1SIPC is notified and takes control of the failed brokerage
- 2Customer accounts are frozen temporarily (usually days to weeks)
- 3SIPC identifies all customer assets and claims
- 4Assets are transferred to a solvent brokerage (your stocks, bonds, etc.)
- 5Any missing assets up to $500,000 are covered by SIPC
- 6Customers regain access at the new brokerage
Are Major Brokerages Actually Safe?
The largest retail brokerages have significant stability:
- These firms survived 2008 without customer losses
- Heavily regulated by SEC, FINRA, and state regulators
- Required to maintain substantial capital reserves
- Too large and systemically important to simply disappear
- Vanguard's structure means it cannot be bought or fail in traditional sense
| Brokerage | Assets Under Management | Safety Features |
|---|---|---|
| Fidelity | $4.5+ trillion | Private, no debt, excess SIPC coverage |
| Schwab | $7+ trillion | Public, bank subsidiary, highly regulated |
| Vanguard | $8+ trillion | Owned by funds/investors, no outside shareholders |
| E*TRADE | Part of Morgan Stanley | Backed by major investment bank |
| TD Ameritrade | Merged with Schwab | Combined strength |
When to Be More Careful
While major brokerages are generally safe, be more cautious with: small or new brokerages, overseas brokerages not SIPC members, cryptocurrency exchanges (not SIPC protected), and any firm offering "too good to be true" returns. Stick with established, SIPC-member firms for retirement assets.
Eliminating Brokerage Risk with Physical Gold
Gold is the ultimate safe haven. Physical gold in an IRA has no counterparty risk - it is yours regardless of what happens to banks, brokerages, or government. Consider gold for ultimate peace of mind:
- Physical gold is stored in secure depositories, not brokerage balance sheets
- You own the metal directly - it is titled in your IRA's name
- No brokerage, bank, or fund company needs to remain solvent
- Gold has preserved wealth through every financial institution failure in history
- Easy to roll over from existing 401k or IRA with no tax consequences
Frequently Asked Questions
1What if I have more than $500,000 with one broker?
If your account exceeds SIPC limits, consider: 1) Splitting between multiple brokerages, 2) Choosing brokerages with excess SIPC coverage (Fidelity covers $1 billion+), 3) Holding some assets in physical form (gold IRA). In practice, properly segregated securities should transfer regardless of SIPC limits.
2Is my 401k safer than a regular brokerage account?
Yes, slightly. 401k assets are held in trust under ERISA, providing additional legal protection. They are separated from your employer's assets and the plan administrator's assets. However, both 401k and brokerage accounts benefit from securities segregation and SIPC protection.
3Should I diversify across multiple brokerages?
For most people, it is unnecessary. A single reputable brokerage like Fidelity, Schwab, or Vanguard is adequately safe. However, if you have $1 million+ or want extra peace of mind, splitting between 2-3 brokerages is reasonable. Alternatively, hold a portion in physical gold which has no brokerage dependency.
4What about the SVB and bank failures - could that happen to brokerages?
Bank failures like SVB are different from brokerage failures. Banks lend out deposits; brokerages hold your securities separately. When SVB failed, depositors were at risk. When brokerages have failed, customer securities were transferred intact. The structure is fundamentally different and more protective for investors.
Related Articles
Helpful Guides
Interactive Tools
Ready to Protect Your Retirement?
Join thousands of Americans who have secured their savings with physical gold. Augusta Precious Metals makes the process simple.